The Blackmaw Hold Gold Exploit: What the Auction House Shows
Players farmed thousands of gold from a bugged dungeon before Blizzard fixed it on November 16. We checked every hourly scan of the Horde auction house from November 10 to 19 for the price jump everyone expected. It is not there. Expensive goods kept getting cheaper through the whole episode, and the few items that did climb started before the farm went public and did not come back down when the farmers were locked out.
What happened, and when
This timeline comes from news reports, not from our data.
| When | What |
|---|---|
| Before Nov 16 | Non-elite enemies in Blackmaw Hold, a level 55 to 60 dungeon, dropped loot as if they were elites. Level 60 characters pulled big packs and sold the coin and gray items to vendors. Reports say it ran for "a few days" and quote 100 to 160 gold an hour. Output Lag |
| Mon Nov 16 | A video made the farm public. Blizzard fixed the drops within hours. Metaforge |
| Tue Nov 17 | Blizzard called it a bug, began removing the gold, suspended the heaviest farmers, and blocked the accounts involved from the auction house and mail while it investigated. Reports put that at around 200 accounts. GamesRadar, Endgame Tools |
One detail matters for reading the market. The gold came from vendors and coin drops, so it was new gold, not goods. If it reached the auction house, it would show up as rich level 60 players bidding up the things they want: raid materials, epics, rare recipes. It would not show up as extra supply.
The test: did expensive goods get dearer?
We took the 5,146 items that were listed in nearly every hourly scan, grouped them by their price on November 13, and followed the typical price in each group. November 13 is 100.
| Group (price on Nov 13) | Items | Nov 13 | Nov 15 | Nov 16 (public, fixed) | Nov 17 (lockout) | Nov 19 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under 1g | 3,824 | 100 | 99 | 100 | 100 | 100 |
| 1g to 10g | 1,136 | 100 | 87 | 85 | 84 | 82 |
| 10g and up | 186 | 100 | 69 | 73 | 64 | 64 |
Goods priced at 10g or more lost 36% in six days. Three out of four of them are cheaper today than on the 13th. The only up-day in that group was November 16 itself, a 3-point bump that was gone the next day. That is the closest thing to an exploit footprint in the data, and it is small enough to be noise.
HordeLedger price index
Launch = 100
The overall price index tells the same story: 33.3 on November 15, 34.4 on the 16th and 17th, 34.7 today. It stopped falling this week, but cheap everyday goods had already gone flat on November 12, before any of this was public.
The exceptions: Arcanite, Mooncloth, Cured Rugged Hide
A handful of level 60 crafting materials did rise in the window. All of them are made on a cooldown or need a slow step, so supply cannot respond quickly.
| Item | Nov 12 or 13 | Peak | Nov 19 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arcanite Bar | 29g 12c (Nov 12) | 58g 18c (Nov 15) | 49g |
| Mooncloth | 17g 90c (Nov 13) | 45g (Nov 18) | 43g |
| Cured Rugged Hide | 14g 05c (Nov 13) | 31g 61c (Nov 18) | 30g 84c |
Arcanite Bar: typical price per day
Middle of the day's market prices
It is tempting to pin these on exploit gold. Two things argue against it. Arcanite doubled between November 12 and 15, before the video. And when the accounts involved lost auction house access on the 17th, none of the three fell back: Arcanite has held near 49g, and Mooncloth and Cured Rugged Hide went higher. Buyers who were not locked out are paying these prices. The plainer explanation is the first wave of level 60 players all needing the same cooldown materials at once. Exploit gold may have added to that demand; this data cannot prove it or rule it out.
What got cheaper anyway
Level 55 to 60 farming of every kind is flooding the house. Runecloth on offer went from about 3,500 units on November 12 to 12,600 today, and the price from 8s 20c to 5s 80c. Illusion Dust went from about 200 units to 1,860, and from 79s to 33s. Green gear for level 51 to 60 went from about 260 pieces listed to 3,860, and its typical price from 5g to 2g 77c. That is what a server looks like when thousands of characters reach the top levels, with or without a bugged dungeon.
How sure is this
- These are asking prices on one auction house (US PvP, Horde). We cannot see sales, gold held by players, or trades made outside the auction house.
- The farm overlapped the launch price slide, when expensive goods were falling 5% to 15% a day. A small push upward could hide inside that.
- We do not know how many of the roughly 200 reported accounts play on this house, or how much gold they kept before the removal.
- The timeline is from press reports. Blizzard has not published the hour of the fix.
What to do
- Don't panic-buy. There is no sign of exploit inflation on this house. Epics, rare gear and high-level materials are still getting cheaper most days.
- Buying Arcanite, Mooncloth or Cured Rugged Hide: these are dear because of cooldowns and raid preparation, not because of a bubble that is about to pop. Buy what you need; don't wait for an exploit correction.
- Selling Runecloth, dust or level 50+ greens: supply is growing faster than demand. Sell as you go.
Data: 208 hourly Horde auction house scans, Nov 8 to Nov 19 11:00 Central. Daily figures are the middle of that day's scans. Economy tracker · Live prices